(631) 851-1507

Book a table

Book a table online and check for availability.

Our Menu

We offer meals and daily specials.


Crispy Calamari

w/crushed plum tomato sauce

**Sliced-Pepper Seared Ahi Tuna

baby greens, eggroll crisp, marinated cucumbers mango-sesame vinaigrette

Lobster Mac & Cheese

creamy orecchiette pasta , tarragon, toasted bread crumb

Prince Edward Island Mussels

pancetta, caramelized onions, roasted tomatoes garlic, white wine, gorgonzola cheese, parsley

Twin Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes

pineapple salsa, avocado, petite greens

Baked Oysters Rockefeller

white wine, spinach, smoked bacon and asiago

Tower Of Crispy Eggplant Milanese

fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, roasted peppers balsamic reduction

Louisiana Shellfish Gumbo

mussels, shrimp, andouille sausage, crawfish and okra in a rich authentic gumbo

Gorgonzola-Apple Salad

granny smith apples, toasted walnuts, crumbled gorgonzola sundried cranberries, sherry- truffle vinaigrette

Organic Baby Greens

shallot rings, goat cheese, candied pecans, fire roasted peppers, tarragon rosemary vinaigrette

Caesar Salad

hearts of romaine, house-made caesar dressing croutons

Skillet Crisp Home Fries

crispy like mom used to make with sweet onions

Cream & Butter Whipped Potatoes

extra creamy love in the mashed potatoes!

Crispy Skin-On French Fries

with Butter’s famous Ailoi dip

BBQ Dry Rubber Fries

sweet BBQ with a light kick

Truffled Parmesan Fries


French Onion Soup

crouton melted mozzarella and gruyere

Daily Chowder

w/ old fashioned oysterette crackers

Penne & Grilled Chicken Gorgonzola

spinach, mushrooms, baby tomatoes, toasted bread crumbs in a roasted garlic cream

Linguini & PEI Mussels Fra Diavolo

topped with fried calamari

Linguini & Clams w/Shrimp

red or white with white wine garlic and parsley

Penne ala Vodka

sweet peas, prosciutto, parmesan, fresh parsley

Our Famous Meatballs & Ricotta

5 balls & Linguini

Beer Battered Onion Rings


House Made Skinny Italian Sausage

w/parsley, grana & provolone cheese, broccoli raab, white beans, fried sweet peppers & onions

Truffle & Herb Roasted Salmon

roasted slab bacon, toasted almonds, brussel sprouts potato parsnip puree

**Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna

gingered shrimp, stir fry veggies, sticky rice sweet soy and wasabi

Chicken Tuscana

marinated, grilled and topped with spinach prosciutto, roasted peppers, melted fontina wild mushroom marsala demi-glace

Chicken Parmigana

breaded, pan fried and topped with crushed tomato sauce and melted mozzarella

8oz. Filet Mignon

white truffle whipped potatoes, broccoli raab

16oz. N.Y. Sirloin Steak

skillet home fries, creamed spinach

Marinated Hanger Steak

whipped potatoes, creamed spinach

New Zealand Rack of Lamb

dijon & brioche crusted, wilted spinach, white truffle potatoes

Parkside Burger

10 oz. Angus Sirloin burger

Bourbon BBQ Burger

smoked bacon, cheddar and frizzled onions

Butterfield “BULL” Burger

smoked bacon, cheddar & fried egg

Spicy California Burger

jalapeños, caramelized onions, bacon, avocado

Jalapeño Peanut Butter Bacon Burger

caramelized onions, bacon, fresh jalapeños

Ultimate Porchetta Sandwich

slow roasted pork shoulder, broccoli raab melted fontina, basil pesto aioli , ciabatta bread

Healthy Tuna & Avocado Pita

tomato, avocado, sprouts, spicy-thai peanut dressing,

Ahi Tuna B.L.T.

on a toasted brioche bun with wasabi aioli

Cuban Sandwich

griddled ham, roasted pork, sauerkraut, pickles, melted swiss, whole grain aioli

Marinated Sliced Steak Sandwich

on toasted ciabatta with melted mozzarella, sauteed mushrooms and onions

Skinny Italian Sausage Sandwich

on a brioche bun topped w/ fried sweet peppers & onions

Upcoming Events

  • Cover Story

    Information and details coming soon!

    12:00 am Friday - June, 3rd

    View Details

  • Blues To Black Street

    Blues to Blackstreet, fronted by the captivating June Eysel , has a very broad appeal. Their style is eclectic but undeniably rooted with one foot always in the blues.

    12:00 am Wednesday - June, 8th

    View Details

  • Rapid Fire

    The tristate area’s fastest rising premier Motown, R&B, dance, concert and show band. The name and the logo are descriptive. These outstanding musicians truly bring the HEAT. You will feel the burn, and your temperature will rise, and you will not be able...

    12:00 am Friday - June, 10th

    View Details

  • Joe Luongo – “The J Effect”

    Pop, rock, classic, new wave ,80,’s, 90’s and todays hits, Joe is a super talented musician playing all types of genres, a list too big to mention, definitely a crowd pleaser and entertainer.

    6:00 pm Wednesday - June, 15th

    View Details

  • The Terri Hines Band

    The Terri Hines Band specializes in “old school” high energy 70’s classic disco/funk dance hits and tears the house down at every venue!

    6:00 am Friday - June, 17th

    View Details

  • Sly Geralds

    Information and details coming soon!

    12:00 am Wednesday - June, 22nd

    View Details

  • Guilty Pleasures

    Whether you were “Workin’ For The Weekend” or “Livin’ On A Prayer” you certainly remember what the Eighties were like! It was a time when totally rad girls wore their legwarmers screaming “What a Feeling” and guys in their parachute pants wore their...

    12:00 am Friday - June, 24th

    View Details

From The Blog


Hauppauge Happy Hour

Happy Hour

Monday to Friday, 4-7 PM


Burger Night


LI Bar Restaurant

Karaoke Night!



Live Bands


LI Dinner & Dancing

DJ & Dancing


See All Specials

Upcoming Events

  1. Cover Story

    Friday, June 3
  2. Blues To Black Street

    Wednesday, June 8
  3. Rapid Fire

    Friday, June 10
  4. Joe Luongo – “The J Effect”

    Wednesday, June 15 @ 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  5. The Terri Hines Band

    Friday, June 17 @ 6:00 am - 9:00 pm
  • Visit us

    New American Cuisine And Steakhouse

    661 Old Willets Path
    NY 11788
    Tel: (631) 851-1507

Come to Butterfields

661 Old Willets Path
NY 11788

Tel:(631) 851-1507
Fax: (631) 851-0712

Get Directions

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am – 12am
Tuesday 11:30am – 12am
Wednesday 11:30am – 12am
Thursday 11:30am – 12am
Friday 11:30am – 2am
Saturday 4:30pm – 2am
Sunday Available for Private Parties

“Like” us on Facebook!