(631) 851-1507

Book a table

Book a table online and check for availability.

Our Menu

We offer meals and daily specials.

$11.95

Crispy Calamari

w/crushed plum tomato sauce
$12.95

**Sliced-Pepper Seared Ahi Tuna

baby greens, eggroll crisp, marinated cucumbers mango-sesame vinaigrette
$13.95

Lobster Mac & Cheese

creamy orecchiette pasta , tarragon, toasted bread crumb
$12.95

Prince Edward Island Mussels

pancetta, caramelized onions, roasted tomatoes garlic, white wine, gorgonzola cheese, parsley
$11.95

Twin Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes

pineapple salsa, avocado, petite greens
$13.95

Baked Oysters Rockefeller

white wine, spinach, smoked bacon and asiago
$10.95

Tower Of Crispy Eggplant Milanese

fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, roasted peppers balsamic reduction
$12.95

Louisiana Shellfish Gumbo

mussels, shrimp, andouille sausage, crawfish and okra in a rich authentic gumbo
$9.95

Gorgonzola-Apple Salad

granny smith apples, toasted walnuts, crumbled gorgonzola sundried cranberries, sherry- truffle vinaigrette
$9.95

Organic Baby Greens

shallot rings, goat cheese, candied pecans, fire roasted peppers, tarragon rosemary vinaigrette
$9.95

Caesar Salad

hearts of romaine, house-made caesar dressing croutons
$4.95

Skillet Crisp Home Fries

crispy like mom used to make with sweet onions
$4.95

Cream & Butter Whipped Potatoes

extra creamy love in the mashed potatoes!
$4.95

Crispy Skin-On French Fries

with Butter’s famous Ailoi dip
$5.95

BBQ Dry Rubber Fries

sweet BBQ with a light kick
$6.95

Truffled Parmesan Fries

$6.95

French Onion Soup

crouton melted mozzarella and gruyere
$6.95

Daily Chowder

w/ old fashioned oysterette crackers
$17.95

Penne & Grilled Chicken Gorgonzola

spinach, mushrooms, baby tomatoes, toasted bread crumbs in a roasted garlic cream
$21.95

Linguini & PEI Mussels Fra Diavolo

topped with fried calamari
$21.95

Linguini & Clams w/Shrimp

red or white with white wine garlic and parsley
$17.95

Penne ala Vodka

sweet peas, prosciutto, parmesan, fresh parsley
$17.95

Our Famous Meatballs & Ricotta

5 balls & Linguini
$5.95

Beer Battered Onion Rings

$21.95

House Made Skinny Italian Sausage

w/parsley, grana & provolone cheese, broccoli raab, white beans, fried sweet peppers & onions
$25.95

Truffle & Herb Roasted Salmon

roasted slab bacon, toasted almonds, brussel sprouts potato parsnip puree
$28.95

**Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna

gingered shrimp, stir fry veggies, sticky rice sweet soy and wasabi
$21.95

Chicken Tuscana

marinated, grilled and topped with spinach prosciutto, roasted peppers, melted fontina wild mushroom marsala demi-glace
$19.95

Chicken Parmigana

breaded, pan fried and topped with crushed tomato sauce and melted mozzarella
$28.95

8oz. Filet Mignon

white truffle whipped potatoes, broccoli raab
$29.95

16oz. N.Y. Sirloin Steak

skillet home fries, creamed spinach
$26.95

Marinated Hanger Steak

whipped potatoes, creamed spinach
$29.95

New Zealand Rack of Lamb

dijon & brioche crusted, wilted spinach, white truffle potatoes
$11.95

Parkside Burger

10 oz. Angus Sirloin burger
$12.95

Bourbon BBQ Burger

smoked bacon, cheddar and frizzled onions
$13.95

Butterfield “BULL” Burger

smoked bacon, cheddar & fried egg
$13.95

Spicy California Burger

jalapeños, caramelized onions, bacon, avocado
$13.95

Jalapeño Peanut Butter Bacon Burger

caramelized onions, bacon, fresh jalapeños
$15.95

Ultimate Porchetta Sandwich

slow roasted pork shoulder, broccoli raab melted fontina, basil pesto aioli , ciabatta bread
$14.95

Healthy Tuna & Avocado Pita

tomato, avocado, sprouts, spicy-thai peanut dressing,
$13.95

Ahi Tuna B.L.T.

on a toasted brioche bun with wasabi aioli
$14.95

Cuban Sandwich

griddled ham, roasted pork, sauerkraut, pickles, melted swiss, whole grain aioli
$14.95

Marinated Sliced Steak Sandwich

on toasted ciabatta with melted mozzarella, sauteed mushrooms and onions
$14.95

Skinny Italian Sausage Sandwich

on a brioche bun topped w/ fried sweet peppers & onions
14.95

Pastrami Swiss Burger

hot pastrami & swiss piled high on our juicy burger
14.95

Hot Pastrami on Rye

Melted swiss and a side of spicy Dijon mustard
13.95

BQ’D Pulled Pork Sandwich

Topped with melted cheddar and beer battered onion rings
$12.95

Crispy Prosciutto Wrapped Shrimp

eggplant componatta, petite caesar greens, EVOO, and aged balsamic reduction

Upcoming Events

  • Live music to resume on Every Wednesday and Friday night during the month of September.

    Stay tuned for our calendar updates!

    8:00 am Wednesday - September, 7th

    View Details

  • Terri Hines Band

    Wed 7th – Terri Hines Band 6-9pm The terri hines band specializes in “old school” high energy 70’s classic disco/funk dance hits……..And tears the house down at every venue!

    6:00 pm Wednesday - September, 7th

    View Details

  • Been There Done That- 60’s and 70’s high energy dance band

    Fri 9th- Been There Done That 9:30- 12:30

    9:30 pm Friday - September, 9th

    View Details

  • PERFECT COMBINATION

    Wed 14th – Perfect Combination 6-9pm “PERFECT COMBINATION” – Donna Lee & Kenny Hendricks of “ That 70’s Band” for a great night of food, spirits, music & dancing! Enjoy this dynamic duo, playing all types of...

    6:00 pm Wednesday - September, 14th

    View Details

  • Acoustic Angry Alice

    Wed 21st – Acoustic Angry Alice 6-9pm Acoustic Angry Alice-Two not so angry ,Very Talented guitarists playing All the Classic rock you know and love… acoustic!

    6:00 pm Wednesday - September, 21st

    View Details

  • North Creek Band

    Fri 23rd – North Creek Band 9:30 – 12:30 North Creek Band- Extremely Talented local classic rock & dance band.

    9:30 pm Friday - September, 23rd

    View Details

  • Terri Hines Band

    Wed 28th – Terri Hines Band 6-9 The Terri Hines band specializes in “old school” high energy 70’s classic disco/funk dance hits……..And tears the house down at every venue!

    6:00 pm Wednesday - September, 28th

    View Details

  • Guilty Pleasures

    Fri 30th Guilty Pleasures 9:30 – 12:30 Whether you were “Workin’ For The Weekend” or “Livin’ On A Prayer” you certainly remember what the Eighties were like! It was a time when totally rad girls wore their legwarmers screaming “What a Feeling” and...

    9:30 pm Friday - September, 30th

    View Details

  • Dee Myers

    Wed 5th – Dee Myers from 6-9pm

    6:00 pm Wednesday - October, 5th

    View Details

  • TBA

    Fri 7th – TBA 9:30 – 12:30

    9:30 pm Friday - October, 7th

    View Details

  • TBA

    Wed 12th TBA 6-9pm

    6:00 pm Wednesday - October, 12th

    View Details

  • Nitework

    Fri 14th Nitework 9:30 – 12:30 We are a 10-piece cover band playing the greatest R&B, funk & rock from the 60’s & 70’s on up. The band is located in Wading River, New York and plays local venues on Long Island and in NYC as well as...

    9:30 pm Friday - October, 14th

    View Details

  • Terri Hines

    Wed 19th Terri Hines Band 6-9pm The terri hines band specializes in “old school” high energy 70’s classic disco/funk dance hits……..And tears the house down at every venue!

    6:00 pm Wednesday - October, 19th

    View Details

  • Legendary Murphy’s

    Fri 21st – Legendary Murphy’s 9:30 – 12:30 THE LEGENDARY MURPHYS classic rock band has been bringing guitar driven rock-n-roll to Long Island and the New York tri-state area since 2001. This group features male and female vocals and plays the greatest...

    9:30 pm Friday - October, 21st

    View Details

  • Perfect Combination

    Wed 26th – Perfect Combination 6-9pm “PERFECT COMBINATION” – Donna Lee & Kenny Hendricks of “ That 70’s Band” for a great night of food, spirits, music & dancing! Enjoy this dynamic duo, playing all types of music!

    6:00 pm Wednesday - October, 26th

    View Details

  • Highview

    Fri 28th – 20 Highview 9:30 – 12:30 20 Highview is an eight piece band covering the classic R & B sounds of the sixties all the way on up to the present day. With focus on the “older”, more classic material, they cover artists such as James...

    9:30 pm Friday - October, 28th

    View Details

From The Blog

Specials

Hauppauge Happy Hour

Happy Hour

Monday to Friday, 4-7 PM

California-Burger

Burger Night

Wednesdays

LI Bar Restaurant

Karaoke Night!

Thursdays

live-band

Live Bands

Fridays

LI Dinner & Dancing

DJ & Dancing

Saturdays

See All Specials

Upcoming Events

  1. Live music to resume on Every Wednesday and Friday night during the month of September.

    Wednesday, September 7 @ 8:00 am - 5:59 pm
  2. Terri Hines Band

    Wednesday, September 7 @ 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  3. Been There Done That- 60’s and 70’s high energy dance band

    Friday, September 9 @ 9:30 pm
  4. PERFECT COMBINATION

    Wednesday, September 14 @ 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  5. Acoustic Angry Alice

    Wednesday, September 21 @ 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm
  • Visit us

    New American Cuisine And Steakhouse

    661 Old Willets Path
    Hauppauge,
    NY 11788
    Tel: (631) 851-1507

Come to Butterfields

661 Old Willets Path
Hauppauge,
NY 11788

Tel:(631) 851-1507
Fax: (631) 851-0712


Get Directions

Opening Hours

Monday 11:30am – 12am
Tuesday 11:30am – 12am
Wednesday 11:30am – 12am
Thursday 11:30am – 12am
Friday 11:30am – 2am
Saturday 4:30pm – 2am
Sunday Available for Private Parties

“Like” us on Facebook!